The Oakland Post

Comments (5)

All The Oakland Post Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Y

    yousefApr 17, 2024 at 12:55 PM

    I am glad to see the GSC see support those with mental health issues and suffering from depression and suicidal thoughts and tendencies. Among the most vulnerable of the mentally ill are the individuals suffering from gender dysphoria. They need love and support to accept that they were wonderful and beautifully made just as they are. we need to stop the barking dogs lying to them telling them they need to mutilate and drug themselves to be “their true selves”.

    Reply
    • C

      ChelseaApr 17, 2024 at 6:09 PM

      Yousef, you do realize that a supermajority of physicians, psychologists, endocrinologists, doctors and scientists all support gender-affirming care. No matter how much you delude yourself, “our true selves” are affirmed through this life-saving medical intervention. Please do more research or just don’t comment at all.

      Reply
      • Y

        yousefApr 18, 2024 at 7:02 AM

        I will not stop commenting until children are no longer lied to, castrated, and mutilated. The late Carl Sagan once said something like appeals to authority are meaningless. Many parts of Europe for example are recognizing the harm these interventions cause. Does this mean either position is true? No.

        Under extreme political pressure barking dogs forced once prestigious medical associations and professionals to capitulate or face consequences; some legal some civil. Gender affirming care is a euphemism for castration and child mutilation. I am sorry you were victim to the propaganda. I urge you to find help accepting you for who you are. You are beautifully and wonderfully made just the way you were intended to be Chelsea.

        one the most evil things the barking dogs do is call evil good and good evil. What they are really doing is putting self destructive ideas into pop culture infecting the youth and diluting them into mental anguish and self doubt. they then prey on them so they can mutilate and castrate them. History will not be kind to them just like it was not kind to lobotomy.

        Reply
        • C

          ChelseaApr 18, 2024 at 12:35 PM

          Do you believe that being gay is still a mental disorder and should be treated with conversion therapy, just like you are suggesting for trans people? Science and progress will always move forwards, despite cowards like you who always hide behind a computer screen and a keyboard. Society will move forward once everyone realizes that trans people are normal people and should be accepted for who they are. Gender affirming care is not only for trans people Yousef. Facial surgery, botox, breast augmentation, hell even hairline restoration – all of it affirms the gender of the recipient.

          When you say many parts of europe, what do you mean exactly? The cass review?? Please, give me a break. That “review” was funded by a transphobe looking to affirm her backwards beliefs and gender critical ideology. They threw away 98 PERCENT of the studies presented to them. Why? For the simple reason that they are not double blinded, but you cannot “double blind” hormone replacement therapy and social transition. It is literally impossible to get good results from taking sugar pills and saline injections. People will notice and so the study would be faulty.

          Politicians lied to you Yousef. It’s not about the children to them, they are going after trans adults as well. Adults, who are consensually taking properly researched medical treatments. These adults usually wait a long time to receive care. I waited two years to receive hormone replacement therapy – during that time, I took a long look at myself and decided that this IS what I want. You wan’t to take that choice away from people. SHAME ON YOU.

          Finally, I am loved Yousef. You may not be, since your heart is clearly full of hatred and vitrol, but I am LOVED. You do not know me, you don’t know my family, you don’t know my day-to-day life, you don’t know my friends and my loved ones. So stop being so judgmental. You don’t know me.

          Reply
          • Y

            yousefApr 18, 2024 at 4:21 PM

            “Do you believe that being gay is still a mental disorder and should be treated with conversion therapy, just like you are suggesting for trans people?”

            Your question also presupposes I support “conversion therapy” which is disparaging charged political term and not a real thing.

            No, I think it is highly improbable having homosexual attractions is a mental disorder. There is a place for those with homosexual attractions in society.

            “Gender affirming care is not only for trans people Yousef. Facial surgery, botox, breast augmentation, hell even hairline restoration – all of it affirms the gender of the recipient”

            Incorrect. these are cosmetic surgeries meant to make those who utilize them “look” better most of the time, not a fundamental redefinition of humanity which forever and all time has had almost without exception men and women until 2 seconds ago in human history. I am also against these types of cosmetic surgeries generally. A case can be made for certain scenarios but aside from freak accidents i dont see a case. They are also not trying to fundamentally redefine language like the barking dogs are.

            my reference to Europe were with respect to the UK and Scandinavian countries taking a shifting stance on these issues away from castration sterilization and mutilation. It was to demonstrate that the use of ad populem reasoning is logically fallacious. I would link an article but OP doesn’t allow them anymore in comments.

            “Politicians lied to you Yousef. It’s not about the children to them, they are going after trans adults as well”

            Those suffering with the mental illness of gender dysphoria should not be told they are the sex they are not. There is nothing good about lying to people. It is like telling a schizophrenic the voices are real. Instead we should show them that there is nothing wrong with them and they are instead beautifully and wonderfully made just the way they are and counsel them to accept that fact.

            I am not a libertarian either i do not believe people should be permitted to do *everything* they want but most of what they want. I do not think people should be permitted to use most drugs, prostitute themselves, sell their organs, or sell themselves into slavery (indentured servitude), consent to sex at any age, or kill themselves (Otherwise known as MAID in Canada).

            This is primarily because we do not live our lives as atomized individuals. EVERYTHING we do has an affect on first ourselves, then our families, then our immediate communities etc all the way to the nation. Our own laws demonstrate this principle in our compulsory education statutes among other places.

            Certain things, such as castration, mutilation, and sterilization, no matter what euphemism you use or “expert” you cite will forever be wrong. I do not need letters after my name to know the moral law written on the hearts of man to know allowing my neighbor to castrate, mutilate or sterilize themselves with no resistance is hateful on my part.

            “Finally, I am loved Yousef. You may not be, since your heart is clearly full of hatred and vitrol, but I am LOVED.”

            On a personal note and only because you mentioned your personal experience; I am sorry you were abused by those around you. You need truth and not lies from those who love you and the doctors who abandoned their oaths who are poisoning you.

            I am not condemning you neither am i hateful. i can see you’re suffering and need help. But it wouldnt be helpful or kind of me to you or anyone reading this to affirm your false perception yourself.