So faculty are bargaining again…
The faculty union has been back at the bargaining table for the past three months, trying to negotiate a fair contract with our administration. Our contract determines our salary, benefits, and our right to shared governance (which means that faculty have a say in how OU is run). I’m writing to catch people up with our situation.
But first: a confession. I hate writing these letters. It’s humiliating.
It’s humiliating for several reasons. The first is that I’m a professional educator. I’ve been teaching English literature and creative writing at OU for 25 years. I love teaching. I love my students. I work hard to try to help them in the classroom and beyond. I co-run Career Night twice a year, bringing back English grads to speak to current students about how they got their jobs. I also co-run our internship program, which gives our students work experience. Before coming here, I taught classes for nine years at Washington University in St. Louis, where I did my PhD.
So yes, I’m a professional educator, but I don’t feel like one when I have to explain why my union is having trouble getting our administration to give us a fair contract. I feel like I’m not valued. The primary mission of a university is to educate students. I feel like that mission is not being prioritized when our administrators begrudge us cost-of-living raises.
Everyone’s been feeling the bite of inflation lately, but here at OU, before the pandemic, faculty salaries had already been lower than the salaries of faculty at our peer institutions. And during the pandemic, we agreed to put bargaining on hold in order to help the university get through that difficult time. But when we came to the bargaining table in 2021, we had one of our most discouraging bargaining sessions on record. Our salaries didn’t go up much (we are still underpaid compared to our peers). And the administration’s bargaining team used strong-arm tactics that left a lot of us feeling upset and depressed.
Now comes my second moment of humiliation. To let you know the reality of how low faculty salaries are here at OU, I have to break a taboo that most Americans never break. I have to tell you how much money I make.
$80,775 a year. I don’t know if that seems like a lot. As I mentioned, I have a PhD. I’m 60 years old; I’ve been teaching classes for 34 years now. But I’m currently unable to put money aside for retirement. I’ve had to cut down on the travel I need to do to research the novels I write. I’ve also had to cut down on the charities I support and the money I give to family members in need.
And here’s the third humiliation. This past Wednesday, our administration said that our two teams can’t discuss faculty raises until we faculty agree to make changes to the shared governance rules that have been in place in our contract ever since the university was founded. They want us to give up our right to have a say in how course workloads are structured at OU. In other words, they want us to organize our English department in the same way we organize our mechanical engineering department, even though each department works quite differently.
I was hired to be a teacher. I know best how my students learn. I don’t know how students from other disciplines best learn, just as those professors don’t understand how my students best learn. And administrators aren’t in the classroom at all. Yet they want exclusive control of how faculty workloads are determined, which ultimately determines how students are taught.
Faculty need to have a say in how classes are organized and taught. And we need to be paid fairly while we do that teaching. Administration is trying to hold hostage raises that are long overdue. They want us to give up our say in shaping how teaching happens, even though teachers are the ones who best understand how to do this work.
I love working at OU, but the faculty need fair pay. We need to continue to have input in our students’ educational experiences. And we need to be respected, not humiliated for doing our jobs as dedicated educators.
Kenneth • Sep 3, 2024 at 2:17 PM
I had many teachers making over 100k a year, some over 200k in highschool. Such a shame that hardly any of my absurd near $10k tuition per semester is going to paying the people that I owe my education to.
G • Sep 1, 2024 at 12:49 PM
I just graduated with my Bachelor’s in English and I’m beyond angry at OU for their continual mistreatment of the professors here. You deserve so much better, and I hope that you get it.
Christine M Stover • Aug 29, 2024 at 9:04 PM
Thank you Annie!
Terri • Aug 29, 2024 at 10:02 AM
Thank you Annie – this is beautifully written! I couldn’t have said it any better and I feel the same way! I love working at OU, but the faculty need fair pay!
yousef • Aug 29, 2024 at 6:30 AM
Annette,
It is pretty bold to post your wages on a public forum. 80k after 34 years experience seems almost insulting. BLS data likely indicates you’re underpaid.
SB • Aug 28, 2024 at 6:49 PM
This is a well-written opinion! Thank you for sharing your story. The faculty at OU deserves better. They are hard working passionate professionals that are not being recognized for their worth.
As a former AP, current adjunct and doctoral student, I truly appreciate the work of the faculty as they have sacrificed much. I hope the administration and Board of Trustees can reach an agreement with the union soon!
James T. • Aug 28, 2024 at 3:45 PM
OU administrators don’t care about faculty. Ora is ensconced in a bubble of sycophants and has been too afraid to face faculty in an open forum since before the pandemic. Meanwhile her chief of staff, a grossly inappropriate hire given his misconduct at Buena Vista, nurtures nothing but contempt for faculty. I fear that little will change until we clean house and hire administrators who understand the core values of our institution.
A.R. • Aug 29, 2024 at 10:12 PM
Of course, they don’t care — that’s autocracy 101. The board and cabinet are not elected authorities accountable to those who elected them. Their SOLE objective is to retain power by any means. In 2021, they were allowed to get away with their abuse. There is NO reason for them not to perpetrate the same thing again.
Liz • Aug 28, 2024 at 12:23 PM
I smell a strike coming. And I support you.
That salary is not appropriate for a university PhD educator with your experience. (And I would guess benefits are less than stellar too?)
For context, working as a RN in West Michigan in a basic hospital role, my yearly salary working 36 hours a week equates to $77k. With weekends and holidays and the like, I will be right about what you make. The pay is the same for associates and bachelor’s educated nurses. I have 10 years RN experience.
I believe some (larger, richer) K-12 school districts in Michigan would pay a teacher with your experience about the same.
Thank you for writing this letter.
Liz, an OU grad (2007)
A Gilson • Aug 29, 2024 at 11:35 PM
Thank you for writing, Liz, and for being so open. You and the community are why we keep fighting.
Special Lecturer • Aug 28, 2024 at 10:13 AM
If it is embarassing to discuss our pay at Oakland, I will also embarass myself. I am a Special Lecturer who has been at Oakland for ten years, meaning I make the most a SL can make. I work a full class load Fall and Winter, also work other jobs on campus including summer camps and orientations. With these combined, I make about $45k a year. I also have almost no savings toward retirement, as Oakland does not offer a retirement plan for Special Lecturers. I love teaching, but the lack of money and the feeling that Oakland does not appreciate my hardwork and dedication is not sustainable.
A Gilson • Aug 29, 2024 at 11:36 PM
I’m so sorry. Stronger together. ❤
Steven • Aug 27, 2024 at 6:18 PM
Beautifully written! It doesn’t seem that much to ask to be heard, valued and understood. OU has continued this type of behavior for as long as I can remember (I retired in 2021 from OU). I was an AP, not a professor, however the treatment is very much the same. I put my heart and sole into the place for most of my working life, yet left feeling as if I beat my head against the wall for most of it.
Good luck to you and all faculty, staff and students!
SK
Rob Anderson • Aug 27, 2024 at 5:26 PM
Terrific letter. It is humiliating. If I thought the administration/Board of Trustees bothered to imagine what their tactics and the contract offers meant to us, I would think that humiliation is the goal. I am confident that it’s part of an effort to keep us in our place.
Sine nomine • Aug 27, 2024 at 5:09 PM
And now, what are the chances that nobody will come to Pescovitz’s faculty gathering? I bet the turnout will be sufficient for her to think everything is honky-dory.
For some reason, communicating a behavioral platitude is next to impossible: the absence of negative reinforcement enables bad behavior. The 2021 negotiating cycle proved that, albeit redundantly, beyond a reasonable doubt. It is absolute foolishness to expect anything better in 2024.