Letter to the editor: destroying a university, 101
If you wish to learn how a thriving university can be systematically dismantled and torn apart, then look around you. Our faculty and student body work to create a vibrant, growing and exciting university but their efforts are repeatedly diminished through incompetence, mismanagement, and political ambition. If you think I’m being overdramatic, consider the facts:
Since 2015, the Oakland administration has decided to spend 65% more on themselves, that is, more pay and more benefits for more administrative positions, while only spending 16% more on student aid and only 4% more on instruction. Does this sound like a university committed to education or simply to taking good care of themselves and their friends?
The recently completed union negotiations with the OU clerical and technical staff, folks with direct contact with students and faculty, concluded with only a one-year commitment to these valuable community members and an insulting $500 “bonus.”
The administration completely botched the “Return to Campus” with a vaccine mandate that was announced far too late for students and faculty to get vaccinated before classes begin, with unrealistic deadlines during classes for vaccine compliance, and with absolutely no procedures or guidance for what to do with students and staff who cannot, or will not, be vaccinated by the October 1 deadline.
The administration positions in the ongoing union negotiations with the university professors – the only folks on campus who actually carry out the mission and work of the university – feature the following:
- Gutting the retirement contributions for full-time faculty – The current faculty retirement contributions were hard-won over a period of nearly 40 years, taken in place of pay raises and dwindling health care benefits. These contributions are often the only “pension” available to retired OU faculty members, many of whom spend their entire careers at OU. Oakland is seeking to slash them, without returning to the benefits the faculty sacrificed to obtain them. By the way, these retirement contributions are only available to 2/3 of the faculty. The administration has steadfastly refused to even offer them to the part-time faculty who teach nearly half the credits at OU.
- Slashing the tuition waiver benefit – Nearly 40 years ago the faculty and Oakland agreed on a procedure where faculty dependents could attend OU at absolutely no cost to the university. Now Oakland claims that the very expensive management software they choose to use cannot accommodate this procedure, and their solution is to slash this benefit – that was specifically designed for faculty to give to each other with no cost to the university – and reap a huge financial windfall.
- Refusing to consider market adjustments to faculty salary – Based on joint faculty/administration market studies done in 2012 and 2015, the OU faculty seriously lag behind their counterparts at universities across the US, and even more so when compared to other comparable research universities. In 2012 and 2015 the faculty was able to get small amounts of money to address this issue, about 10% of what was necessary. This administration, however, now steadfastly refuses to consider market adjustments to salary or even acknowledge the existence of the problem.
- Eviscerating summer pay – Because OU faculty are grossly underpaid and happen to work in one of the most affluent and expensive counties in the US, it should come as little surprise that many, many OU faculty teach in their “off” semester to supplement their incomes. And by now it should be no surprise that Oakland is looking to slash this opportunity, offering to drastically cut summer pay and looking to substitute even lower-cost, inexperienced, part-time faculty for the important work of educating our students.
- Seeking to dictate how courses are taught – Oakland is also trying to use the pandemic as an excuse to attempt to take control of how courses are to be offered, in-person or online. For 27 years the faculty have had the right to decide how a course will be taught, but now Oakland, blessed with a faculty who pivoted online over the span of 4 days in March 2020 to continue to teach and nurture students, is now looking to exploit those same faculty and force them to teach in ways that have been shown to be ineffective, unpopular, but much more profitable.
- Reducing faculty salaries – Even though it has been shown the OU faculty is already underpaid, the administration is intent on reducing faculty salaries. The “raise” money the administration has offered is actually less than the amounts that the administration plans to take away through higher insurance premiums and tuition payments, and reduced summer pay and retirement contributions. We are hardly surprised, for this is the same administration that moved half of the millions of Federal dollars they received for student Covid relief into “reserve funds,” out of sight and out of touch for students and faculty.
Yes, Oakland University is being systematically dismantled and destroyed by its own administration, as faculty, students and staff are desperately trying to prepare to learn in the upcoming semester. Are we going sit by and watch, or are we going to make our voices heard?
Michael Latcha, PhD joined OU in 1986, is an associate professor of Mechanical Engineering, and has been a member of seven faculty bargaining teams, leading the last four as the chief negotiator.
Letters to the editor can be submitted to [email protected].
Steph • Sep 2, 2021 at 12:04 PM
I’ve created a petition that anyone can sign, in solidarity with faculty. The link to sign and share is https://bit.ly/OUAAUPcn
Lesley Lambright • Aug 28, 2021 at 8:40 PM
As a Professor emeritus from Macomb College with 34 years of teaching and counseling, I can fully support what is being stated. It is a nationwide debacle that begin with moving to a business model over 35 years ago and has compromised colleges and universities across the country.
I mourn for what was and grieve for what is to come. Students are not being rigorously taught and instructors are not being paid properly nor supported professionally. It is a tragedy of American education.
Ann • Aug 27, 2021 at 4:59 PM
I have never heard anyone express the importance of administrators when deciding which university to attend or what they appreciate about their educational experiences.
If attracting and retaining students is important to OU it must be able to attract and retain a high caliber of faculty. The only way to do that is to show the commitment to value and support faculty with a fair contract.
Michael • Oct 15, 2021 at 9:43 AM
“I have never heard anyone express the importance of administrators when deciding which university to attend or what they appreciate about their educational experiences.”
Ann-2021
Kriss Kross • Aug 27, 2021 at 11:30 AM
“many OU faculty teach in their “off” semester to supplement their incomes.”…Wow–wish I had an “off” semester…
Ben Katchor • Aug 27, 2021 at 10:50 AM
Here’s one possible solution: https://publicseminar.org/2018/08/newschool-coop-envisioning-a-cooperative-university/
haik fedcharian • Aug 27, 2021 at 10:17 AM
Some who read this article might be interested in what feedback the author’s students have given him, since he was so open providing feedback regarding his administration: https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/ShowRatings.jsp?tid=375322
Anonymous • Aug 27, 2021 at 7:41 AM
Thank you Dr. Latcha for your clear and concise presentation of the current contract negotiation circumstances — And for your continued efforts on behalf of all of your colleagues. The Administration’s refusal to maintain benefits at their current levels and to offer reasonable salary increases leaves me at a loss for words. Like many of my colleagues, I personally worked 70 hour weeks since March 11, 2019, so that students could experience quality online instruction and much-needed mentoring. My online courses are rigorous and engaging while delivering the same content as students would experience in the classroom. The University should be proud and supportive of our efforts, but it is clear that they are not. In short, their intentions to pay us as little as possible, and to cut benefits is astonishingly difficult to understand. It is absolutely demoralizing.
Anonymous • Aug 26, 2021 at 7:53 PM
To be sure, the “Oakland administration” we’re talking about here isn’t some nebulous entity—it’s made up of actual people like Ora Pescovitz and Britt Rios-Ellis. They may not sit at the bargaining table, but they run the show. Long after bargaining is over, we will remember how they stood by in support of malicious, regressive policies that hurt our faculty. Dr. Pescovitz and Dr. Rios-Ellis don’t deserve our confidence unless they do something to stop this contemptuous assault on our institution.
Michael • Oct 15, 2021 at 9:40 AM
The Oakland University administration is full of weak spineless invertebrates.
Like Dr. “All-Star” Latcha says in his article they botched the mandate, and didnt let students organize any kind of feedback on their “mandate”. they waited for other universities to take the heat from the media before they slipped their mandate in weeks before classes start.
It seems to me they are a bunch of overpaid fools bleeding the life out of an otherwise excellent university while ignoring there core constituency, students and professors. Trim the administrative fat, know that administrators take years to train, and professors take decades to train, and student tuition dollars pay you. YOU are replaceable, WE are not.
Momma Grizzly • Aug 26, 2021 at 7:40 PM
Oakland’s shenanigans has made many lose all trust in the administration. The outright lie that the everyone should run out and get their “shots” because they are FDA approved now. They aren’t — Pfizer Comirnaty is the only approved vaccine, but not available. Pfizer BioNTech is still under the Emergency Use Authorization and the corporation has no liability if you are injured.
Dr. Thyro • Aug 26, 2021 at 7:26 PM
Proof that colleges continue to evolve into being nothing but adult day care centers, as Bill Maher recently put it: https://youtu.be/_x5SeXNabd8
It’s time to dismantle the excess of administrative jobs and BS
“support staff” positions designed to help admins hire friends and political pawns and get back to having more actual full-time faculty jobs that happen to have a few administrative responsibilities instead, like in the olden days.
Anonymous • Aug 26, 2021 at 6:55 PM
Try being an adjunct here. No guarantee, nothing. For decades.
courtney l pullman • Aug 26, 2021 at 6:11 PM
Great article. Incredibly sad though.
Amanda Hugg • Aug 26, 2021 at 4:26 PM
Even though we are not represented by the union, several student-facing APs (not the ones in the ivory tower who claim they provide dubious academic support) stand in solidarity with OU faculty.
Nigel • Aug 26, 2021 at 3:38 PM
Thank you Mike Latcha. For this article and your continued support and service to OU faculty.
OU is systematically destroying shared governance, academic freedom and now they are not letting a good pandemic go to waste by using it as an excuse to cut faculty salaries, benefits and total compensation while they are concurrently lining their pockets.
Anonymous • Aug 26, 2021 at 12:14 PM
That is to say, the OU administration has discredited itself from the top down. If they have a single shred of conscience left, they should repent or resign.